Devils vs Stars Best Bets: Oct 27, 2026
Devils vs Stars best bets for Oct 27, 2026: full-game Under 5.5 goals and 1st period Under 1.5 goals, with timestamped odds.

Final score: New Jersey Devils 5, Dallas Stars 1 (Oct 27, 2026). Pick results: full-game Under 5.5 goals at -102 lost (six total goals); 1st period Under 1.5 goals at -106 won (Nico Hischier's goal at 2:41 was the only 1st-period goal).
The Dallas Stars enter Tuesday's matchup against the New Jersey Devils as modest home favorites, with the full-game total set at 5.5 goals and the over slightly favored. However, we believe the market is placing too much emphasis on the potential for a higher-scoring game. Our two selections are built around the same underlying trend: Dallas has consistently kept games low-scoring, with particularly limited offensive production during the first period.
For team news, projected lineups and a complete breakdown of the matchup, read our Devils vs Stars match preview.
Game Info
- New Jersey Devils at Dallas Stars
- Tuesday, October 27, 2026, 8:00 PM ET, American Airlines Center
- Probable goalies: New Jersey TBD (Jake Allen or Connor Hellebuyck, neither confirmed) vs. Jake Oettinger (DAL, projected, unconfirmed; Casey DeSmith possible)
Market Snapshot
All prices below are from DraftKings as of Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET, unless another bookmaker is specified.
- Moneyline: Devils +105, Stars -125
- Puck line: Devils +1.5 at -258, Stars -1.5 at +210
- Total goals: Over 5.5 at -118, Under 5.5 at -102
- Devils team total: Over 2.5 at -150, Under 2.5 at +110
- Stars team total: Over 2.5 at -165, Under 2.5 at +125
- 1st period total: Over 1.5 at -120, Under 1.5 at -110
- 2nd period total: Over 1.5 at -154, Under 1.5 at +120
- 3rd period total: Over 1.5 at -188, Under 1.5 at +145
- Total goals at FanDuel, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET: Over 5.5 at -118, Under 5.5 at -104
- 1st period total at FanDuel, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET: Over 1.5 at -120, Under 1.5 at -106
Pick 1 (Main Pick): Under 5.5 Goals at -102 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET)
FanDuel offers the same bet at -104 (FanDuel, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET), making DraftKings the slightly better-priced option.
Our main selection is supported by one of the clearest statistical trends in this matchup. Dallas has consistently participated in some of the NHL's lowest-scoring games, yet the market offers a price close to even money on another contest finishing with five goals or fewer.
- Ten of Dallas's 11 games have finished with five goals or fewer. The only exception was Sunday's 6-3 victory over the Islanders.
- Dallas allows a league-low 1.73 goals per game and just 21.7 shots per game. Oettinger, the projected starter, has recorded three shutouts in nine starts. If Casey DeSmith starts instead, he carries a 1.94 GAA and .925 save percentage this season.
- Five of New Jersey's 11 games have also finished with five goals or fewer, and the Devils have allowed just five goals combined across their last three contests.
- Across both teams' schedules, 15 of 22 games have finished under 5.5.
- Dallas owns the NHL's second-best penalty kill at 92.3 percent, reducing one of the most common sources of additional scoring.
- Risk: New Jersey leads the NHL in shots per game, presenting a significant challenge to Dallas's defensive structure. The Devils' goaltending situation also remains uncertain, with the starter yet to be decided between Allen (.886 save percentage) and Hellebuyck, who has not appeared in a game this season. Overtime goals count toward the total, and two of Dallas's last three games have required overtime.
The strongest argument for this selection is Dallas's remarkable defensive consistency. The Stars have built their success around limiting opposing shot volume, protecting dangerous scoring areas and relying on reliable goaltending rather than high offensive output.
Their ability to suppress shots makes them particularly difficult opponents for teams that depend on sustained offensive pressure. New Jersey's league-leading shot generation will test that approach, but Dallas has repeatedly demonstrated its ability to control the pace of games and limit scoring opportunities.
The goaltending matchup also supports a potentially low-scoring contest, particularly if Oettinger starts as projected. His performances have been central to Dallas's defensive success, and DeSmith's numbers suggest the Stars have another capable option if the starting assignment changes.
New Jersey's recent defensive improvement provides additional support. Although the Devils have not been as consistently involved in low-scoring games as Dallas, their ability to limit goals over their last three outings suggests they can contribute to a more controlled matchup.
The primary concern is New Jersey's uncertainty in goal. Allen's save percentage introduces some risk, while Hellebuyck's lack of game action this season makes his potential impact difficult to assess. Nevertheless, Dallas's defensive profile remains the central reason for backing the under.
We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at roughly 60 to 62 percent, well above the implied probability of about 50 percent at the listed price.
Pick 2: 1st Period Under 1.5 Goals at -106 (FanDuel, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET)
DraftKings offers the same bet at -110 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET), giving FanDuel the more attractive price.
Our second selection focuses on Dallas's consistently quiet opening periods. The Stars have rarely been involved in high-scoring starts, making the first-period under a natural extension of our main pick.
- Only 12 goals have been scored in the first periods of Dallas's 11 games, with six scored and six allowed.
- Eight of Dallas's 11 first periods have produced one goal or fewer.
- Five of New Jersey's 11 first periods have also finished with one goal or fewer.
- Across both teams' schedules, 13 of 22 first periods have stayed under 1.5.
- Seven of New Jersey's 11 first periods have ended tied, suggesting a tendency toward cautious, closely contested starts.
- Risk: This selection is correlated with our main pick, meaning an unexpectedly fast start could put both wagers at risk. New Jersey's opening periods have also been more eventful than Dallas's, with six of 11 finishing over 1.5.
Dallas's first-period numbers provide the strongest foundation for this market. The Stars have consistently limited early scoring opportunities, and their defensive approach has prevented opponents from establishing immediate offensive momentum.
That style is particularly relevant against a New Jersey team capable of generating substantial shot volume. Dallas will likely prioritize defensive positioning, controlled possession and limiting dangerous opportunities rather than committing unnecessary resources to early offensive pressure.
New Jersey's tendency to finish opening periods tied provides another supporting angle. Although those results do not necessarily guarantee low scoring, they suggest the Devils have frequently remained competitive without establishing large early advantages.
However, the difference between the two teams' first-period scoring patterns is important. Dallas has been considerably more consistent in keeping opening periods quiet, while New Jersey has participated in more high-scoring starts.
That discrepancy makes this a lower-confidence selection than the full-game under. The wager depends on Dallas successfully imposing its preferred defensive structure early, particularly against a Devils team with the offensive talent to generate chances quickly.
We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at roughly 56 to 58 percent, above the implied probability of about 51 percent. We recommend a lighter stake than on the main pick.
What We Are Passing On
- Stars moneyline at -125 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET): Dallas is our preferred side, but three of its five consecutive victories have come by a single goal, with all three decided beyond regulation. While the Stars deserve to be favored, those narrow results provide limited comfort at the listed price.
- Stars -1.5 at +210 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET): Dallas has won by two or more goals in only four of 11 games. Its tendency to play tightly contested, low-scoring games makes a multi-goal victory less compelling, despite the attractive potential return.
- Devils team total Under 2.5 at +110 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET): Dallas has held eight of 11 opponents to two goals or fewer, which supports the under. However, New Jersey has scored at least three goals in eight of 11 contests. Those opposing trends create uncertainty and reduce our confidence in this market.
- 3rd period Under 1.5 at +145 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET): Dallas has been effective at limiting opposing scoring during the final period, but the Stars have scored at least once in the third in eight of 11 games. Additionally, eight of New Jersey's 11 third periods have featured two or more goals. Those patterns make this market less attractive than the first-period under.
Summary
- Main pick: Under 5.5 goals at -102 (DraftKings, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET)
- Second pick: 1st period Under 1.5 goals at -106 (FanDuel, Oct 27, 2026, 8:10 AM ET)
- Suggested staking: 1 unit on the main pick, 0.75 units on the second pick
Both selections are built around Dallas's outstanding defensive structure, reliable goaltending and remarkable consistency in keeping games low-scoring.
Our main pick targets the full-game scoring environment, supported by the Stars' defensive statistics and the frequency with which their games have finished below the posted total. The second selection focuses specifically on Dallas's disciplined opening periods, where limited scoring has been an especially consistent trend.
The two markets are closely correlated, meaning a fast-paced, high-scoring start could undermine both positions. For that reason, we recommend keeping stakes modest rather than treating the selections as independent opportunities.
Track these selections and all our other calls on the NHL picks page, review the full public record on predictions, or put your own picks to the test against the community in Saint Picks tournaments.
Odds were accurate at the bookmaker and time listed but may change before puck drop. Always check the current price with your sportsbook before placing a bet.
Bet responsibly
Sports betting is for adults only: you must be 18+ (19+ in Ontario) and of legal betting age where you live. Treat betting as entertainment, set a budget before the puck drops, never chase losses and only bet what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 (Ontario) or 1-800-GAMBLER (US) for free, confidential help.
Want an AI read on a matchup?
The Bet Analyzer researches one game and scores your bet — form, injuries and value in one scan.
Open the Bet AnalyzerNHL Hockey Simulator
Available to PRO members · 10,000 simulations per matchup. Estimates, not guarantees.
Today's Saint Picks nhl picks
Moneylines, puck lines and totals for tonight's NHL games, with staking guidance.
Free betting tools
Written by the Saint Picks analysis team. Official picks are settled against Flashscore results. About us
More articles
All articles
MacKinnon, Makar Questionable for Saturday's Game in Montreal
Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar are questionable with lower-body injuries for Colorado's game at Montreal on Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. ET.

NHL Recap Nov 12, 2026: Scores, Standouts and Betting Results
NHL recap for Thursday, November 12, 2026: Boldy's hat trick, Jets score eight in Dallas, Senators win in OT, and how the Saint Picks card settled.

NHL Recap Nov 11, 2026: Scores, Standouts and Betting Results
NHL recap for Wednesday, November 11, 2026: Kucherov's hat trick in an 8-3 Lightning win, Bouchard's OT goal, Predators' sixth straight and all six scores.
For entertainment and analytical purposes only. 18+. Bet responsibly. Saint Picks is not a casino or sportsbook.