Lightning vs Avalanche Best Bets: Oct 23, 2026
Lightning vs Avalanche best bets Oct 23, 2026: 3rd Period Under 2.5 Goals as the main pick, plus 2nd Period Over 1.5 Goals, with timestamped odds.

Final score: Colorado Avalanche 6, Tampa Bay Lightning 3 (Oct 23, 2026). Pick results: 3rd period Under 2.5 goals at -172 lost (three goals in the 3rd period); 2nd period Over 1.5 goals at -180 won (four goals in the 2nd period).
The market makes Colorado a modest home favorite against the hottest team in the Atlantic, and the full-game lines look fairly priced. The stronger opportunities are in the period markets, where both teams have followed clear patterns this season: Colorado does most of its offensive damage in the second period, while Tampa Bay has been effective at shutting games down in the third.
For team news, projected lineups and the full game storyline, read our Lightning vs Avalanche match preview.
Game Info
- Tampa Bay Lightning at Colorado Avalanche
- Friday, October 23, 2026, 9:00 PM ET, Ball Arena
- Probable goalies: Andrei Vasilevskiy (TBL, projected, unconfirmed) vs. Mackenzie Blackwood (COL, projected, unconfirmed)
Market Snapshot
All prices below are from DraftKings as of Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET, unless another bookmaker is specified.
- Moneyline: Lightning +105, Avalanche -125
- Puck line: Lightning +1.5 at -238, Avalanche -1.5 at +195
- Total goals: Over 6.5 at +102, Under 6.5 at -122
- Lightning team total: Over 3.5 at +135, Under 3.5 at -175
- Avalanche team total: Over 3.5 at +115, Under 3.5 at -155
- 1st period total: Over 1.5 at -140, Under 1.5 at +110
- 1st period puck line (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET): Lightning +0.5 at -215, Avalanche -0.5 at +165
- 2nd period total: Over 1.5 at -180, Under 1.5 at +140
- 3rd period total: Over 2.5 at +135, Under 2.5 at -175
- 3rd period total at FanDuel, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET: Over 2.5 at +134, Under 2.5 at -172
Pick 1 (Main Pick): 3rd Period Under 2.5 Goals at -172 (FanDuel, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET)
DraftKings offers the same bet at -175 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET), making FanDuel the better option. This market covers regulation third-period goals only.
- Tampa Bay has stayed under 2.5 third-period goals in eight of nine games. The only exception was its 4-3 overtime win against Seattle on Oct. 15. The Lightning have scored nine third-period goals while allowing only four.
- Colorado has stayed under in seven of 10 games. The exceptions were its 8-4 win against Los Angeles, its 7-3 win in Calgary and its 4-3 loss in New Jersey, when two of the four third-period goals came with an empty net or an extra attacker on the ice.
- Combined, the two teams have stayed under 2.5 third-period goals in 15 of 19 games.
- Tampa Bay allows only 24.2 shots per game, one of the lowest totals in the league, and has protected leads effectively in the third period, winning the final frame in five of nine games.
- Risk: With Colorado a narrow favorite, a one-goal game late in the third period could prompt a pulled goalie and a quick flurry of goals, as happened in New Jersey on Tuesday.
We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at roughly 70 to 72 percent, above the implied probability at the listed price.
Pick 2: 2nd Period Over 1.5 Goals at -180 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET)
FanDuel offers the same bet at -182 (FanDuel, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET).
- Colorado has seen two or more second-period goals in nine of 10 games, failing only in New Jersey on Tuesday. The Avalanche have outscored opponents 20-10 in second periods, averaging three goals per middle frame.
- Tampa Bay has gone over 1.5 second-period goals in six of nine games, including a three-goal second period in Vegas on Tuesday.
- Combined, the two teams have reached two or more second-period goals in 15 of 19 games.
- Colorado leads the NHL with 34 five-on-five goals, and the long change in the second period suits its pace-driven style.
- Risk: Tampa Bay's structure is designed to limit this type of game. Three of its nine second periods produced only one goal, and Vasilevskiy can take over a period on his own.
We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at close to 70 percent. The price is steeper, and Tampa Bay's defensive profile adds risk, so we recommend a lighter stake.
What We Are Passing On
- Moneyline: Lightning +105 and Avalanche -125 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET). Tampa Bay is 7-1-0 in its last eight, but it is 2-2-0 on the road and plays again in Utah on Saturday. Colorado is rested and playing at home but has lost three of its last four. Neither side offers enough of an edge.
- Total 6.5: Over at +102 and Under at -122 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET). Colorado has reached seven goals in six of 10 games, while Tampa Bay has done so in only three of nine. The opposing trends largely cancel each other out.
- 1st period Over 1.5 at -140 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET): Both teams have seen two or more first-period goals in seven of their games, making this a close alternative. However, Colorado has had two scoreless first periods, and Tampa Bay has allowed just eight first-period goals in nine games. We therefore prefer the second-period angle.
- Lightning +1.5 at -238 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET): Tampa Bay has lost by two or more goals only twice, but Colorado has won by two or more four times. The price leaves no value.
- Shots on goal: We could not find team or player shots-on-goal lines priced near 50/50 with a verified bookmaker and timestamp, so we are not recommending any.
Summary
- Main pick: 3rd period Under 2.5 goals at -172 (FanDuel, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET)
- Second pick: 2nd period Over 1.5 goals at -180 (DraftKings, Oct 23, 2026, 8:20 AM ET)
- Suggested staking: 1 unit on the main pick, 0.75 units on the second pick
Track these selections and all our other calls on the NHL picks page, review the full public record on predictions, or put your own picks to the test against the community in Saint Picks tournaments.
Odds were accurate at the bookmaker and time listed but may change before puck drop. Always check the current price with your sportsbook before placing a bet.
Bet responsibly
Sports betting is for adults only: you must be 18+ (19+ in Ontario) and of legal betting age where you live. Treat betting as entertainment, set a budget before the puck drops, never chase losses and only bet what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 (Ontario) or 1-800-GAMBLER (US) for free, confidential help.
Want an AI read on a matchup?
The Bet Analyzer researches one game and scores your bet — form, injuries and value in one scan.
Open the Bet AnalyzerNHL Hockey Simulator
Available to PRO members · 10,000 simulations per matchup. Estimates, not guarantees.
Today's Saint Picks nhl picks
Moneylines, puck lines and totals for tonight's NHL games, with staking guidance.
Free betting tools
Written by the Saint Picks analysis team. Official picks are settled against Flashscore results. About us
More articles
All articles
MacKinnon, Makar Questionable for Saturday's Game in Montreal
Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar are questionable with lower-body injuries for Colorado's game at Montreal on Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. ET.

NHL Recap Nov 12, 2026: Scores, Standouts and Betting Results
NHL recap for Thursday, November 12, 2026: Boldy's hat trick, Jets score eight in Dallas, Senators win in OT, and how the Saint Picks card settled.

NHL Recap Nov 11, 2026: Scores, Standouts and Betting Results
NHL recap for Wednesday, November 11, 2026: Kucherov's hat trick in an 8-3 Lightning win, Bouchard's OT goal, Predators' sixth straight and all six scores.
For entertainment and analytical purposes only. 18+. Bet responsibly. Saint Picks is not a casino or sportsbook.