Hockey
Best bets & value analysis·Published October 22, 2026·5 min read

Rangers vs Maple Leafs Best Bets: Oct 22, 2026

Rangers vs Maple Leafs best bets for Oct 22, 2026: third-period total and first-period picks with timestamped DraftKings and FanDuel odds.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs Best Bets: Oct 22, 2026

Final score: Toronto Maple Leafs 5, New York Rangers 4 (Oct 22, 2026).

The market sees Rangers at Maple Leafs as a coin flip, and the full-game odds reflect that uncertainty. The clearest opportunities lie in the period markets. Both picks are backed by patterns that have held throughout the season: Toronto rarely produces high-scoring third periods, while the Rangers have been exceptionally difficult to beat in the opening frame.

For team news, projected lineups and the full game storyline, read our Rangers vs Maple Leafs match preview.

Game Info

  • New York Rangers at Toronto Maple Leafs
  • Thursday, October 22, 2026, 7:00 PM ET, Scotiabank Arena
  • Probable goalies: Dylan Garand (NYR, projected, unconfirmed) vs. Sergei Bobrovsky (TOR, projected, unconfirmed)

Market Snapshot

All prices below are from DraftKings as of Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET, unless another bookmaker is specified.

  • Moneyline: Rangers -112, Maple Leafs -108
  • Puck line: Rangers -1.5 at +220, Maple Leafs +1.5 at -270
  • Total goals: Over 6.5 at -105, Under 6.5 at -115
  • Rangers team total: Over 3.5 at +125, Under 3.5 at -165
  • Maple Leafs team total: Over 3.5 at +115, Under 3.5 at -155
  • 1st period total: Over 1.5 at -140, Under 1.5 at +110
  • 1st period puck line (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET): Rangers +0.5 at -215, Maple Leafs -0.5 at +165
  • 2nd period total: Over 1.5 at -180, Under 1.5 at +140
  • 3rd period total: Over 2.5 at +135, Under 2.5 at -175
  • 3rd period total at FanDuel, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET: Over 2.5 at +128, Under 2.5 at -164

Pick 1 (Main Pick): 3rd Period Under 2.5 Goals at -164 (FanDuel, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET)

DraftKings offers the same bet at -175 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET), making FanDuel the better option.

Toronto has been one of the league's most consistent teams for third-period unders, and the overall scoring profile of this matchup supports a relatively quiet final 20 minutes.

  • Toronto has recorded three or more goals in a third period just once in 11 games, during its 4-1 home loss to the Islanders on Oct. 17. The Leafs have scored 10 goals and allowed 8 in third periods this season.
  • New York has gone over 2.5 third-period goals in five of 11 games, making this the main source of risk. Three of those five overs came in home wins against Utah, Vancouver and Anaheim. On the road, only the 3-0 loss in Boston and the 7-1 loss in New Jersey went over.
  • Combined, the two teams have stayed under 2.5 third-period goals in 16 of 22 games.
  • Both teams boast elite penalty kills. Toronto ranks first in the NHL at 97.4 percent, while New York ranks second at 94.1 percent. Those numbers reduce the likelihood of power-play goals opening up the game late.
  • Risk: In a closely contested game, a late empty-net situation is the biggest threat. A 2-1 or 3-2 scoreline can quickly produce three goals in the period if a goalie is pulled. The Rangers have also been involved in several late-goal finishes, including two Anaheim goals in the final 70 seconds on Monday.

We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at roughly 68 to 70 percent, comfortably above the implied probability at the listed price.

Pick 2: Rangers +0.5 1st Period at -215 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET)

FanDuel offers the same bet at -230 (FanDuel, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET). This selection wins if the Rangers lead or are tied at the end of the first period.

  • New York has outscored opponents 10-3 in first periods and has lost only one opening frame in 11 games: the 7-1 loss in New Jersey. Its first-period record stands at seven wins, one loss and three ties.
  • On the road, the Rangers have avoided losing the first period in four of five games, even while struggling to score overall.
  • Toronto has won the first period just three times in 11 games and has trailed after 20 minutes in six of them.
  • New York wins 53.9 percent of its faceoffs, the third-best rate in the league, helping the Rangers control the pace early.
  • Risk: The price is steep, and a single Toronto power play could change the complexion of the period. Matthews, Nylander and Marchenko give the Leafs the high-end skill to score in bunches, as demonstrated by their four-goal second period in Columbus.

We estimate the probability of this pick hitting at close to 70 percent. The edge is smaller than that of the main pick, so we recommend a lighter stake.

What We Are Passing On

  • Moneyline: Rangers -112 and Maple Leafs -108 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET). The Rangers are 1-3-1 on the road, while Toronto has been inconsistent at home at 3-3-1. Neither side offers a sufficiently clear advantage to justify a pick.
  • Total 6.5: Over at -105 and Under at -115 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET). Toronto's games have reached seven goals in six of 11, compared with just four of 11 for New York. The contrasting trends make this market difficult to call.
  • Rangers team total Under 3.5 at -156 (FanDuel, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET): New York has scored three or fewer goals in all five road games but four or more in all six home games. Toronto has allowed four or more goals in five of 11 games. The road split is worth considering, but the overall evidence is not strong enough to make it a full pick.
  • 1st period Under 1.5 at +110 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET): New York's first-period results support the under, but Toronto has seen two or more goals in the opening period in seven of 11 games.
  • Shots on goal: We could not find team or player shots-on-goal lines priced near 50/50 with a verified bookmaker and timestamp, so we are not recommending any.

Summary

  • Main pick: 3rd period Under 2.5 goals at -164 (FanDuel, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET)
  • Second pick: Rangers +0.5 1st period at -215 (DraftKings, Oct 22, 2026, 8:25 AM ET)
  • Suggested staking: 1 unit on the main pick, 0.75 units on the second pick

Track these selections and all our other calls on the NHL picks page, review the full public record on predictions, or put your own picks to the test against the community in Saint Picks tournaments.

Odds were accurate at the bookmaker and time listed but may change before puck drop. Always check the current price with your sportsbook before placing a bet.

Bet responsibly

Sports betting is for adults only: you must be 18+ (19+ in Ontario) and of legal betting age where you live. Treat betting as entertainment, set a budget before the puck drops, never chase losses and only bet what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 (Ontario) or 1-800-GAMBLER (US) for free, confidential help.

Want an AI read on a matchup?

The Bet Analyzer researches one game and scores your bet — form, injuries and value in one scan.

Open the Bet Analyzer

NHL Hockey Simulator

Available to PRO members · 10,000 simulations per matchup. Estimates, not guarantees.

View simulator

Today's Saint Picks nhl picks

Moneylines, puck lines and totals for tonight's NHL games, with staking guidance.

Written by the Saint Picks analysis team. Official picks are settled against Flashscore results. About us

More articles

All articles

For entertainment and analytical purposes only. 18+. Bet responsibly. Saint Picks is not a casino or sportsbook.