Schaefer's First NHL Hat Trick Helps Islanders Beat Blue Jackets
Matthew Schaefer scored his first NHL hat trick as the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, at UBS Arena.

Matthew Schaefer scored his first NHL hat trick, and the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at UBS Arena in Elmont, N.Y. The 19-year-old defenseman is the third in Islanders history to record a hat trick, and the first since Denis Potvin on March 4, 1982, NHL.com's recap reported.
Anthony Duclair and Tony DeAngelo each had a goal and an assist, Mathew Barzal added two assists, and Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves as New York improved to 10-6-4 and won its third straight game. Zach Werenski scored for Columbus (7-12-0), which has lost five consecutive games in regulation. Cam Talbot made 36 saves. The records that came with the hat trick are detailed in NHL.com's feature on Schaefer.
How the Islanders pulled away
Duclair opened the scoring on the power play at 19:02 of the first period. DeAngelo started the play from the left point, Duclair moved the puck to Barzal, and Duclair finished a return feed from the high slot, beating Talbot glove side, per NHL.com. The man advantage came after Columbus forward Cole Sillinger took a minor at 17:18, drawn by Emil Heineman.
Schaefer doubled the lead at 1:34 of the second, scoring unassisted with a wrist shot from above the right circle on a prone Talbot, glove side.
Werenski cut the deficit to 2-1 at 1:12 of the third, skating past Ryan Pulock down the left wing, cutting across the crease and scoring on Sorokin. Kent Johnson and Luca Del Bel Belluz had the assists.
Schaefer answered at 7:01 to make it 3-1, backhanding a rebound from Pulock's slap shot into an open net, with Duclair getting the second assist. Columbus challenged for goaltender interference; the call on the ice was confirmed.
DeAngelo made it 4-1 at 11:52, taking a Barzal drop pass along the right boards, driving to the crease and roofing a backhand over Talbot's blocker. Matias Maccelli had the second assist. With Talbot off for an extra attacker, Schaefer completed the hat trick into an empty net at 16:08, assisted by Simon Holmstrom and Bo Horvat.
The Islanders outshot Columbus 41-29. Schaefer had nine shots and played 23:23. He was named the first star; Duclair and DeAngelo were the second and third stars.
Schaefer adds to the teenage record book
Schaefer, born September 5, 2007, in Stoney Creek, Ontario, was the No. 1 pick in the 2025 NHL Draft. When he scored to make it 2-0, he became the second defenseman in NHL history to reach 30 career goals as a teenager, after Hockey Hall of Famer Phil Housley, who had 46, NHL.com reported.
His second goal of the night gave him six career multigoal games, passing Housley's five for the most by a teenage defenseman in NHL history. It was also his 17th career multipoint game, tying Ray Bourque for the second-most by a teenage defenseman. Housley is first with 34. NHL.com said Schaefer passed Larry Murphy and Rick Hampton on that list in the same game.
He finished with 24 points (nine goals, 15 assists) through 20 games this season, tying Murphy's 1980-81 total for the second-most by a teenage defenseman through 20 games. Housley had 25 in 1983-84. The NHL's official player page later listed Schaefer with 32 career goals and 102 games played. He also has 10 points (five goals, five assists) in a six-game point streak.
"All these things, it's just crazy to hear. It's an honor," Schaefer said, per NHL.com. "You don't think about things like that, but obviously when you hear it, it's pretty cool. But you just want to keep focusing on your season and what we've got going on in here." Barzal, who is in his 10th full NHL season, added: "We're watching greatness kind of evolve."
Sorokin and a three-game surge
Sorokin stopped 28 of 29 shots in 60 minutes. New York has outscored its opponents 16-5 during the three-game winning streak, including a 5-2 win at the Los Angeles Kings on November 12 and a 6-2 win at the Anaheim Ducks on November 14. The Islanders are fourth in the Metropolitan Division and ninth in the Eastern Conference, with 24 points in 20 games.
Coach Peter DeBoer pointed past the individual records. "As great as (Schaefer) is and all the records he's broken, I really think tonight was about our entire group," he said, per NHL.com, also crediting Barzal, Duclair and DeAngelo.
What it means for the Islanders going forward
New York now takes the streak on the road. The Islanders visit the Winnipeg Jets on Thursday, November 19, 2026, at 7:00 PM ET at Canada Life Centre, according to the official NHL schedule. They then play at the Detroit Red Wings on Saturday, November 21, at 7:00 PM ET, before hosting the Toronto Maple Leafs at UBS Arena on Monday, November 23, at 7:30 PM ET.
The form is clear: three straight wins, a six-game point streak for Schaefer, and another strong night from Sorokin. How that carries into Winnipeg, with Detroit two nights later, is the next test. No pick is being made here, and no sportsbook price is quoted.
For the latest card, see our NHL picks. The rest of Tuesday's results are in our November 17 NHL recap. For an earlier look at this Islanders group, see our Islanders vs. Sharks preview from November 9.
FAQ
When did Matthew Schaefer score his first NHL hat trick?
On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, in a 5-1 Islanders win over the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena. His goals came at 1:34 of the second period and at 7:01 and 16:08 of the third; the last was an empty-net goal.
Is he the first Islanders defenseman with a hat trick?
No. NHL.com says he is the third defenseman in Islanders history to record one, and the first since Denis Potvin on March 4, 1982.
What records did the game add?
He became the second teenage defenseman to reach 30 career goals, after Housley. He passed Housley with six career multigoal games, the most by a teenage defenseman. He tied Bourque for the second-most multipoint games by a teenage defenseman, with 17. He also has 10 points in a six-game point streak.
Where do the Islanders play next?
At the Winnipeg Jets on Thursday, November 19, 2026, at 7:00 PM ET, at Canada Life Centre.
Bet responsibly
18+ (19+ in Ontario). Betting should be fun, never a way to make money. If gambling stops being fun, call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 or 1-800-GAMBLER.
Want an AI read on a matchup?
The Bet Analyzer researches one game and scores your bet — form, injuries and value in one scan.
Open the Bet AnalyzerNHL Hockey Simulator
Available to PRO members · 10,000 simulations per matchup. Estimates, not guarantees.
Today's Saint Picks nhl picks
Moneylines, puck lines and totals for tonight's NHL games, with staking guidance.
Free betting tools
Written by the Saint Picks analysis team. Official picks are settled against Flashscore results. About us
More articles
All articles
NHL Recap Nov 18, 2026: Scores, Standouts and Betting Results
NHL recap Nov 18, 2026: Bruins 4-1 at Detroit, Canadiens 3-2 at New Jersey, Mammoth 4-1 over Colorado, plus our 0-4, -3.5u picks review.

Stars vs Golden Knights Preview & Best Bets: Nov 19, 2026 NHL Pick
Stars at Golden Knights, Nov 19, 2026 rematch: form, injuries, goalies, head-to-head and our best bet: Stars moneyline (+106 FanDuel), 0.5 units.

Canadiens Beat Hurricanes 2-1 in OT: Recap, Key Stats & Betting Review
Canadiens beat Hurricanes 2-1 in OT on Nov. 19, 2026: final score, scorers, key stats and how our picks settled.
For entertainment and analytical purposes only. 18+. Bet responsibly. Saint Picks is not a casino or sportsbook.