Soccer
News roundup·Published November 2, 2026·3 min read

Isak Penalty Row: Timber Shirt Pull Sparks VAR Fury as Arsenal Win at Anfield

Timber's shirt pull on Isak went unpunished as Arsenal won 1-0 at Anfield. Iraola: 'you have to dive'. Hackett says penalty and maybe red.

Isak Penalty Row: Timber Shirt Pull Sparks VAR Fury as Arsenal Win at Anfield

Arsenal left Anfield on Sunday with a 1-0 win and top spot in the Premier League. In Liverpool, people were talking about something else: a shirt pull that nobody gave.

Kai Havertz scored early, turning in Declan Rice's low cross at the far post. Arsenal had not won a league game at Anfield in 14 years, and the result put them three points clear of Manchester City, who lost to Brighton on Saturday. The talk after the game, though, was about a first-half moment that most people inside the stadium seemed to miss.

The shirt pull

Bradley Barcola crossed into the Arsenal box and Alexander Isak lined up a header at goal. The Sweden striker just failed to reach it and the ball drifted out for a goal kick. Isak turned and jogged back without a word of complaint.

Replays told a different story. Jurrien Timber had a handful of Isak's shirt, arm stretched out, as the striker went for the ball. Referee Andy Madley did not see it. The VAR, Stuart Attwell, decided there was not enough in it to recommend a review, as BBC Sport's Dale Johnson explained. The understanding is that officials saw a brief tug with minimal impact rather than sustained holding.

"You have to dive"

Liverpool head coach Andoni Iraola did not hold back. "There is a clear grab of the shirt," he told Match of the Day. "Alex was just in front of him, he was going to head in front of the goal but couldn't because he grabbed the shirt."

"If he goes to the floor, they call the penalty 100%," he added. "The answer is you have to dive. If you don't dive they won't call it."

Asked by Sky Sports whether he would tell Isak to go down next time, Iraola said: "Yes, definitely." He also felt Liverpool should have had a second penalty when Christos Tzolis held Cody Gakpo, although Gary Neville, on co-commentary, said there was "not enough in it". In his press conference, Iraola reportedly said any retrospective verdict from PGMOL, which he expected in 10 to 12 days, would not change the result.

Virgil van Dijk was blunter about the technology. "There are 50 cameras. Even more. Why does he have to complain when there are so many cameras?" Mikel Arteta said he had not seen the incident back and had no comment.

Pundits and an ex-refs chief agree

On Sky's Super Sunday panel, Jamie Carragher had a simple message: "VAR, do your job." Ian Wright and Daniel Sturridge also said Isak should not have had to make more of it, according to Sky Sports.

Keith Hackett, the former head of PGMOL, went further. "The referee should have been invited to view the monitor, this was a clear offence and Liverpool should have had a penalty kick," he told Football Insider. He added that if the penalty had been given, Timber "should have been red carded for the denial of an obvious goal scoring opportunity."

Not everyone agrees. Former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann told the BBC that "some will say it was sustained, some will say it wasn't", and noted that Isak did not even appeal. With this season's high bar for VAR interventions, it may go down as an on-field error that never reached the threshold for a review.

So far there is no official word from PGMOL. Some social media posts claim the referees' body has already admitted a mistake, but no reliable report confirms it.

The headbutt that wasn't

The second flashpoint went the other way. Late in the second half, Alexis Mac Allister fouled Martin Odegaard and slapped him on the back of the head. Noni Madueke confronted him, their foreheads touched, and Mac Allister went down holding his face. VAR checked it, Madueke stayed on, and Mac Allister was booked.

Carragher called it "embarrassing" and "a joke". Madueke told Viaplay that Mac Allister "tried to bait me into getting a red card".

What it means

Liverpool did not manage a shot on target all afternoon, which takes some of the heat out of the "what if". Even so, a converted penalty around the 20-minute mark would have changed the game. Arsenal now sit on top, and the debate over holding, diving and VAR will carry on.

For our full pre-match read, see our Liverpool vs Arsenal prediction and the Liverpool vs Arsenal best bets. You can find this week's picks on our predictions page and follow every competition on our tournaments page.

*18+ only. Please gamble responsibly.

Want an AI read on a matchup?

The Bet Analyzer researches one game and scores your bet — form, injuries and value in one scan.

Open the Bet Analyzer

Soccer Match Simulator

Available to PRO members · 10,000 simulations per matchup. Estimates, not guarantees.

View simulator

Today's Saint Picks soccer predictions

Premier League, LaLiga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Champions League and more — published before kickoff.

Written by the Saint Picks analysis team. Official picks are settled against Flashscore results. About us

More articles

All articles

For entertainment and analytical purposes only. 18+. Bet responsibly. Saint Picks is not a casino or sportsbook.